Research featured in the American Journal of Nutrition suggests that consuming unprocessed red meat twice a week could heighten the risk of developing type 2 diabetes by 51%. This condition impairs the body’s ability to utilize insulin effectively, and while dietary changes alone can suffice for some, others might need medication intervention.
Dr. Xiao Gu, the study’s principal investigator and a Harvard postdoctoral research associate, recommends limiting red meat to once, and at most twice, per week.
Substituting red meat with plant-based protein sources has been associated with a lower diabetes risk, according to the study’s findings. Plant-based proteins offer a high content of beneficial unsaturated fats, in contrast to the saturated fats predominant in red meat.
Dr. Gu emphasizes the significance of transitioning to plant proteins from red meat to bolster public health. This study underlines the necessity of understanding how diet influences diabetes risk, the health benefits of plant proteins, and the imperative of diabetes risk reduction for overall well-being.
Table of Contents
Red meat’s role in disrupting insulin regulation is multifaceted.
Grace Derocha, a registered dietitian and certified diabetes educator, emphasizes that saturated fats in red meat can undermine the cells that produce insulin, diminishing insulin sensitivity. This disruption can lead to insufficient insulin production for controlling excess blood sugar.
Red meat’s deficiency in polyunsaturated fats (PUFAs) also elevates the risk of developing type 2 diabetes. Contrastingly, introducing PUFA-rich foods, particularly those containing linoleic acid, can potentially reverse insulin resistance.
Another problematic component in red meat is heme iron, which contributes to oxidative stress, thereby exacerbating insulin resistance and impairing insulin-producing cells.
Additionally, processed red meats contain nitrates, which can promote insulin resistance and lead to endothelial dysfunction. This condition involves the narrowing of the heart’s blood vessels, leading to chronic chest pain and is more common in women.
Derocha suggests that while red meat need not be entirely excluded, awareness of its impact on various health aspects is essential, advocating for a balanced approach to its consumption.
Switching to plant-based proteins could offer significant advantages for insulin regulation compared to red meat.
Dr. Xiao Gu points out that plant-based proteins, abundant in unsaturated fats and lower in saturated fats, can help avert the progression toward type 2 diabetes.
In discussions with Health, Gu emphasized the protective benefits of a diet centered around plant proteins, noting the potential for a marked decrease in type 2 diabetes risk, with broader implications for public health.
The study under Gu’s lead examined the diets of over 200,000 U.S. adults, establishing a persistent link between higher red meat consumption and an increased risk of diabetes, even when controlling for factors such as BMI.
In line with guidance from the American Diabetes Association, Gu underscores the importance of moderating red meat consumption, highlighting the benefits of a diet that favors plant proteins for better health outcomes across the board.
Individuals aiming to cut back on red meat have numerous alternative sources of protein to choose from, as recommended by Derocha:
- Chicken and turkey
- Fish and shellfish
- Garbanzo beans
- Sugar peas
- A broad assortment of beans and lentils
- Tofu and other soy-based items
- Natto, a traditional Japanese fermented soy dish
- Edamame, or young soybeans
- Dahl, or hulled and split beans
- Time-honored grains like farro and barley
- Nutrient-rich spirulina
- Versatile seeds like quinoa and chia
A Call to Reevaluate Diets Amidst Rising Diabetes
With diabetes cases surging both in the United States and around the world, Dr. Gu emphasizes the critical need to reassess dietary habits. He advocates for a dietary shift towards plant proteins and moderate dairy consumption over red meat.
The latest figures from the CDC are concerning, revealing that more than 10% of Americans are battling diabetes, many unknowingly.
Highlighting the necessity for proactive measures, Gu points out that preventing diabetes is crucial. The disease not only poses serious health risks on its own but also increases susceptibility to cardiovascular and kidney diseases, as well as cancer and dementia.
The gravity of the situation is further echoed by the 2019 GBD report, which associates almost a million deaths globally with the intake of unprocessed red meat.
Despite these stark statistics, Derocha, speaking with Health, cautions against a one-size-fits-all approach to red meat consumption, advocating for personalized dietary advice to accommodate individual health needs.
- Red meat intake and risk of type 2 diabetes in a prospective cohort study of United States females and males
- Life doesn’t end with type 2 diabetes
- Best protein choices for diabetes
- National Diabetes Statistics Report
- Worldwide burden attributable to diet high in red meat from 1990 to 2019